Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Judith Newman 🇨🇦's avatar

The challenge is this - our "culture" offers no really good conversation openers for this situation of a friend acknowledging a close death. Judaism at least has shiva where friends can come and openly share condolences - that first face-to-face meeting that is so complicated. Much more difficult where there aren't cultural rituals to handle the situation.

So I say "I offer my condolences" or as they say in police dramas when the cops first meet the family of a deceased "I'm sorry for your loss." (probably just as good). But that next from a friend - "What can I do to help you?" Pointless - at that moment the only reply is "There isn't anything!" Truth is, there isn't anything. We bring food that fills the freezer but offers little comfort. Even when you've already been there yourself and you know the platitudes your friends offer are unhelpful, we have nothing else to fall back upon. As a society we're not good at handling death and dying!

Yesterday, I visited a friend in rehab trying to recover from a moderate stroke - her right side is paralyzed. She can speak if slowly. My challenge was trying to find anything to ask her that wasn't "How was she doing?" - it was obvious she's struggling. Her world has narrowed to such an extent conversation is almost impossible, not because she can't speak, she can, but because there's almost nothing to talk about except the struggle she's facing!

It's hard to be on the receiving end of friends' best intentions. It's hard being on the "giving" end, as well.

Expand full comment
Ann Richardson's avatar

Beautifully written. Reminds me of when I had a miscarriage (not the same loss, but my husband is still breathing) and you heard the same phrases over and over again. My particular bugbear is the word 'condolences' which sounds like if you say it, it's all done and, moreover, one size fits all. Age 83 (and husband 85), I feel time's winged chariot moving your situation towards me.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?