46 Comments

Thank you, Peter. It was quite sublime.

Expand full comment

A beautiful warm story Peter. Thank you for reminding me of my mother and her life of music.

Expand full comment

What a lovely, moving tribute to your mom and all she gave you, Peter. And so touching that you were able to give back to her in return. You describe her so vividly.

Expand full comment

Peter: What sensitivity you bring to describing mom and her deep connection to music; and what tenderness you brought to taking care of her in her old age.

Lucky mother, lucky son!

And lucky sister! :-)

Expand full comment

This was so lovely and evocative. Perfect use of dialogue. You brought your mom to life with your words.

Expand full comment

I enjoyed but felt like I was standing outside a restaurant window on a cold blustery day looking inside at people enjoying a good, warm meal. Didn't have that kind of relationship with my mother and my father killed in traffic accident when eight. Nevertheless, I can still feel the warmth and love of your relationship. Thank you for sharing as Beethoven--especially his Ode to Joy--always helps elevate my moods.

Expand full comment

Beyond lovely.

Exquisitely beautiful.

It’s been awhile since I so felt something I’d read.

Expand full comment

This is satin smooth and... sublime. I'm going to use the word frequently and also bookmark this essay because I just love the refined elegance of the dear woman, your mother. How inspirational she seems.

Thank you for this - a lovely read.

Expand full comment

Just beautiful! Your writing captures your very essence.

Expand full comment

You're very kind, thank you Sandi!

Expand full comment

I knew your mother and heard her play the piano. This narrative is exquisite as was her playing.

Expand full comment

This is exquisite - brought tears to my eyes. For me, it's Bach that makes me glad to be alive. But Beethoven's not bad either. Thank you!

Expand full comment

Thank you Beth for your lovely comment. Bach does that for me, too!

Expand full comment

Lovely memories…..what a beautiful story, so well written. Thanks Peter

Expand full comment

Thank you Lisa, I'm happy that you responded to it.

Expand full comment

Beautiful, Peter. I have to admit, I envy that closeness you had with your mum and your classical education. Mine was all about hollyweird, and it doesn't compare.

What a lovely tribute of your mum that is, too. No doubt the music is what kept her alive 'till 105, and her ability to share it with you!

Expand full comment

I think you're absolutely right that music can sustain us.

By the way, the "Hollyweird" stories must be fascinating in themselves!

Expand full comment

Interesting, if you like that kind of thing, but not the soul-food that a musical education must have been!

Expand full comment

How wonderful that you had your mother for such a long and full lifetime, Peter. This is a beautiful tribute to her and to the power of music.

Expand full comment

Thank you for your comment, I'm happy that you responded to the story.

By the way, my mother was a sensitive Jewish grandmother, too.

Expand full comment

Thank you for evoking my own memories of music -Beethoven, Chopin, Bill Evans, Tord Gustavsen, hymn, "In The Garden", my son's composition "On My Way". Music is a balm.

Expand full comment

Thanks for this, Sandra. I'm glad this piece spoke to you and brought back your own fine memories.

Expand full comment

Wonderful, heartfelt memories, Peter. Beautifully written. I'm sure if she was with us today, she would find words other than "crude" and "ordinary" to describe Mr. Trump. Hugh

Expand full comment

Thanks very much for your comment. I'm glad you responded to this piece.

Yes, she was certainly a lover of words; it's a shame we can't hear which ones she might choose to describe that man.

Expand full comment